Five stars applied carefully

I’ve been reviewing books for a while now and giving scores out of five for each one on an ad-hoc basis depending on how I felt about the book. As I now seem to be reviewing a lot more books I decided that I needed to put a defined assessment structure in place.

Therefore, until such time as I decide something better suits, I will use the following criteria:-

    1 star = Terrible – couldn’t finish the book. Do not recommend to anyone (on Amazon = I hate it)

    2 stars = Poor – the storyline may have been good, but there were factors that spoilt the enjoyment of reading the book. Factors could be: the style of writing; the quality of the writing or things such as gratuitous sex or violence. Book only recommended to readers who can tolerate these. (on Amazon = I don’t like it)

    3 stars = Average – a good book with a good story. Well written and enjoyable to read. Recommended to readers of the genre. (on Amazon = it’s ok)

    4 stars = Very good – An extremely enjoyable read, well written and with an engaging storyline. Nothing off putting and highly recommended. (on Amazon = I like it)

    5 stars = Excellent – a book so well written that it compels you to just keep on reading. The storyline loses you completely into another world. Nothing else matters but reading the book. The highest recommendation a book can get. (on Amazon = I love it)

I may also go back and re-grade some of the books I have previously reviewed to bring them in to line with these criterion, over a period of time of course.

Advertisements

120 thoughts on “Five stars applied carefully

  1. Pingback: Curse Breaker: Enchanted [The More Epic Version] by Melinda Kucsera – Julie Short

  2. Pingback: The Wolf (The Under The Northern Sky Series, Book 1) by Leo Carew – Julie Short

  3. Pingback: The Breast Reconstruction Guidebook: Issues and Answers from Research to Recovery by Kathy Steligo – Julie Short

  4. Pingback: Spellsmith & Carver: Magicians’ Rivalry by H. L. Burke – Julie Short

  5. Pingback: Damaged beyond all recognition by Alan Felyk – Julie Short

  6. Pingback: Clockwork City [Delphic Division 2] by Paul Crilley – Julie Short

  7. Pingback: The Liar’s Girl by Catherine Ryan Howard – Julie Short

  8. Pingback: The Hazel Wood by Melissa Albert – Julie Short

  9. Pingback: Pendragon by Mike Weatherley – Julie Short

  10. Pingback: A Man of Shadows by Jeff Noon – Julie Short

  11. Pingback: Keeper of the Watch by Kristen L. Jackson – Julie Short

  12. Pingback: Beyond Burning Sands by P R Adams – Julie Short

  13. Pingback: Keeper by Kim Chance – Julie Short

  14. Pingback: The Girl in The Tower by Katherine Arden, – Julie Short

  15. Pingback: WaR: Wizards and Robots by will.i.am & Brian David Johnson – Julie Short

  16. Pingback: Elysium Fire by Alastair Reynolds – Julie Short

  17. Pingback: We Care For You by Paul Kitcatt – Julie Short

  18. Pingback: Broadcast by Liam Brown – Julie Short

  19. Pingback: The Australian Concern by Jan Reyneke – Julie Short

  20. Pingback: The Cruel Prince by Holly Black – Julie Short

  21. Pingback: The Argentine Intervention by Jan Reyneke – Julie Short

  22. Pingback: The Pets at Primrose Cottage: Part One A Place to Hide by Sheila Norton – Julie Short

  23. Pingback: Beasts of Extraordinary Circumstance by Ruth Emmie Lang – Julie Short

  24. Pingback: Gnomon by Nick Harkaway – Julie Short

  25. Pingback: A Thousand Rooms by Helen Jones – Julie Short

  26. Pingback: Sorcery for Beginners A Simple Help Guide to a Challenging & Arcane Art by Matt Harry – Julie Short

  27. Pingback: Elmet by Fiona Mozley – Julie Short

  28. Pingback: Thinblade (Sovereign of the Seven Isles Book 1) by David A. Wells – Julie Short

  29. Pingback: The Art of Hiding by Amanda Prowse – Julie Short

  30. Pingback: The Last Librarian (Book One of the Justar Journal) by Brandt Legg – Julie Short

  31. Pingback: Blood and Stars (Legend of Rhyme Series Volume 1 Book 5 ) by Jaime Lee Mann – Julie Short

  32. Pingback: The Darkness Within by Lisa Stone  – Julie Short

  33. Pingback: Samhain Heartsong by Doranna Durgin – Julie Short

  34. Pingback: How to Stop Time by Matt Haig – Julie Short

  35. Pingback: The Reckoners by Doranna Durgin – Julie Short

  36. Pingback: A Child Made to Order by Piotr Ryczko – Julie Short

  37. Pingback: The People at Number 9 by Felicity Everett – Julie Short

  38. Pingback: Beneath Burning Sands by P R Adams – Julie Short

  39. Pingback: How to be Human by Paula Cocozza – Julie Short

  40. Pingback: Strange the Dreamer by Laini Taylor – Julie Short

  41. Pingback: Sometimes I Lie By Alice Feeney – Julie Short

  42. Pingback: The Vets at Hope Green: Part Three Too Close to Home by Sheila Norton – Julie Short

  43. Pingback: Let The Dead Speak: A Maeve Kerrigan crime thriller by Jane Casey – Julie Short

  44. Pingback: Defective by Autumn Kalquist – Julie Short

  45. Pingback: The Future Chronicles – Special Edition by Samuel Peralta – Julie Short

  46. Pingback: Everything But The Truth by Gillian Mcallister – Julie Short

  47. Pingback: The Vets at Hope Green part 2: Follow your heart by Sheila Norton – Julie Short

  48. Pingback: The Hand in Shadow by JD Lovil – Julie Short

  49. Pingback: Momentary Stasis by P R Adams – Julie Short

  50. Pingback: The Vets at Hope Green: Part One Escape to the Country by Sheila Norton – Julie Short

  51. Pingback: The Girl Before by J P Delaney – Julie Short

  52. Pingback: The Devils prayer by Luke Gracias – Julie Short

  53. Pingback: “Grave Predictions (Tales of Mankind’s Post-Apocalyptic, Dystopian and Disastrous Destiny) by Stephen King; Greg Bear; Ramsey Campbell; Joe R. Lansdale; Carmen Maria Machado; Mark Samuels; Erica L. Satifka; Brian Stableford; Ray Bradbury; Arthur C.

  54. Pingback: Dragonsong by Michael Forester – Julie Short

  55. Pingback: The One Memory of Flora Banks by Emily Barr – Julie Short

  56. Pingback: The Spy by Paulo Coelho – Julie Short

  57. Pingback: The Forgotten Tale (The Accidental Turn Series, Book 2) by J M Frey – Julie Short

  58. Pingback: The Untold Tale (The Accidental Turn Series, Book 1) by J M Frey – Julie Short

  59. Pingback: The Legends of Camber of Culdi Trilogy (Camber of Culdi, Saint Camber, and Camber the Heretic) by Katherine Kurtz – Julie Short

  60. Pingback: Distress Signals A Novel by Catherine Ryan Howard – Julie Short

  61. Pingback: Immortal Writers Immortal Writers Series Book 1 by Jill Bowers – Julie Short

  62. Pingback: The Reader by MK Harkins – Julie Short

  63. Pingback: The Heretic (Book One of Beyond the Wall) by Lucas Bale – Julie Short

  64. Pingback: The Grace of Kings by Ken Lui – Julie Short

  65. Pingback: Nirvana (Nirvana Series Book One) by J.R. Stewart – Julie Short

  66. Pingback: The forgotten ones: Book 1 (The Danaan Trilogy) by Laura Howard – Julie Short

  67. Pingback: The Promise of the Child by Tom Toner – Julie Short

  68. Pingback: Holding by Graham Norton – Julie Short

  69. Pingback: Rise of the Chosen Lifeblood Series #1 by Anna Kopp – Julie Short

  70. Pingback: Poison City by Paul Crilley – Julie Short

  71. Pingback: Descent (The Dream Protocol Book #1) by Adara Quick – Julie Short

  72. Pingback: Slow Dough Real Bread by Chris Young – Julie Short

  73. Pingback: Homo Deus A Brief History of Tomorrow by Yuval Noah Harari – Julie Short

  74. Pingback: Missing, Presumed by Susie Steiner – Julie Short

  75. Pingback: The Secret Diary of Hendrik Groen, 83 ¼ Years Old by Hendrik Groen – Julie Short

  76. Pingback: Hide and Seek DI Helen Grace 6 by M. J. Arlidge – Julie Short

  77. Pingback: Revenger by Alastair Reynolds – Julie Short

  78. Pingback: The Inscription by Pam Binder – Julie Short

  79. Pingback: Night Draws In By C.H. Alexander – Julie Short

  80. Pingback: Finder (First Ordinance, #1) by Connie Suttle – Julie Short

  81. Pingback: Cancer with a small ‘C’ by Elizabeth Caush – Julie Short

  82. Pingback: Lady of Devices (A Steampunk Adventure Novel) by Shelley Adina – Julie Short

  83. Pingback: Local Girl Missing by Claire Douglas – Julie Short

  84. Pingback: Preserving Hope (The Aliomenti Saga – Book 2) by Alex Albrinck – Julie Short

  85. Pingback: A Feral Darkness by Doranna Durgin – Julie Short

  86. Pingback: Subject 375 (The Spider in the corner of the Room) by Nikki Owen – Julie Short

  87. Pingback: Allegiant by Veronica Roth – Julie Short

  88. Pingback: Subject 375 (The Spider in the corner of the Room) by Nikki Owen – Julie Short

  89. Pingback: Insurgent by Veronica Roth – Julie Short

  90. Pingback: All is not forgotten by Wendy Walker – Julie Short

  91. Pingback: Second Twin (Legend of Rhyme Series Volume 1 Book 4) by Jaime Lee Mann – Julie Short

  92. Pingback: Beyond the Aquila Rift by Alastair Reynolds – Julie Short

  93. Pingback: The Singularity Saga: Book 1 Dawn of the Singularity by David Simpson – Julie Short

  94. Pingback: Cooking for Chemo …and After! by Chef Ryan Callahan – Julie Short

  95. Pingback: The Medusa Chronicles By Stephen Baxter and Alastair Reynolds – Julie Short

  96. Pingback: The Singularity Saga: Book 1 Dawn of the Singularity by David Simpson – Julie Short

  97. Pingback: Julie Short

  98. Pingback: A Question of Will The Aliomenti Saga – Book One by Alex Albrinck – Julie Short

  99. Pingback: Fortress of Owls by C J Cherryh – Julie Short

  100. Pingback: Maker review  – Julie Short

  101. Pingback: Night Study by Maria V. Snyder – Julie Short

  102. Pingback: Divergent by Veronica Roth – Julie Short

  103. Pingback: The Right Bite by Jackie Lynch – Julie Short

  104. Pingback: Not if I see you first by Eric Lindstrom – Julie Short

  105. Pingback: Writer (Daughter of Time trilogy, Book 2) by Erec Stebbins – Julie Short

  106. Pingback: Reader | Julie Short

  107. Pingback: Night Study by Maria V. Snyder | Julie Short

  108. Pingback: Soulless (The girl in the box series, book 3) by Robert J Crane | Julie Short

  109. Pingback: Untouched (The girl in the box series, book 2) by Robert J Crane | Julie Short

  110. Pingback: Alone | Julie Short

  111. Pingback: Invasion (Grumpy Old Wizards series, Book 6) by John O’Riley | Julie Short

  112. Pingback: Nirvana (Nirvana Series Book One) by J.R. Stewart (final edition) | Julie Short

  113. Pingback: The Grace of Kings by Ken Lui | Julie Short

  114. Pingback: The forgotten ones: Book 1 (The Danaan Trilogy) by Laura Howard | Julie Short

  115. Pingback: Nirvana (Nirvana Series Book One) by J.R. Stewart     | Julie Short

  116. Pingback: Teagan of Tomorrow (Legend of Rhyme Series Volume 1 Book 3) by Jamie Lee Mann | Julie Short

  117. Pingback: Dragon Keeper by Robin Hobb | Julie Short

  118. Pingback: Slow bullets by Alastair Reynolds | Julie Short

  119. Pingback: Nirvana (Nirvana Series Book One) by J.R. Stewart | Julie Short

  120. Pingback: Ship of Destiny by Robin Hobb | Julie Short

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s